

written by Chris Miller and Phil Lord, directed by Pamela Fryman
This is the first episode of the show that was not written by series creators Carter Bays and Craig Thomas. Chris Miller and Phil Lord, who are both Dartmouth graduates, only wrote one other episode of HIMYM, but are credited as co-executive producers on 17 episodes. Miller and Lord would go on to write the screenplays for Extreme Movie and Cloudy With A Chance of Meatballs.
"Sweet Taste of Liberty" begins with Ted wanting to spend Friday evening at McLaren's. However, Barney wants to get Ted out of his rut, and he makes plans to go somewhere else. Somewhere legendary. To Ted, McLaren's is safe; it comes guaranteed with an above average amount of fun. A "legendary" night with Barney usually does not live up to the hype. Still Ted reluctantly gets into a cab with Barney, and their night begins.
Barney mentions to Ted that he needs to stop at the airport to pick someone up. Ted finds out that Barney actually plans to hit on chicks and pick them up. They meet a couple of girls who are flying to Philadelphia, and after talking with them for less than a minute, they decide to buy some tickets and follow them to Philly. As it turns out, the girls are going to Philly to see their boyfriends.
Meanwhile in the B story, Marshall is at home studying, while Lily and Robin are having a girls night out at McLaren's. The allure of a night in Philly with his bros is too much for Marshall, and he jumps in his car and starts driving. At McLaren's, Lily is frustrated that so many guys are hitting on Robin, while none are even giving her a second glance.
When the flight lands, airport security take Barney and Ted to a room where they are interrogated due to Barney abandoning (forgetting) his bags at JFK. Ted tells the truth to security, who don't seem to buy it. However, they are cleared once JFK security finds that the abandoned bags are just filled with condoms. The night still has a chance to be "legendary" as Sasha, an airport employee, invites them over for a party. But the party turns out to be two other dudes drinking hard lemonade in her basement.
Back at McLaren's, Lily has removed her engagement ring to try to get guys to hit on her, but it still doesn't work. Finally, a guy comes over to her, but it's not to hit on her. He's gay, and he just wants to tell her that she sat on a grape. Marshall calls Lily's phone, which Robin answers, letting him know that Lily has taken her ring off and that she's talking to a guy. Marshall turns around and heads back to New York. He somehow gets back fairly quick, and he enters McLaren's just as the gay guy is dabbing Lily's butt with some club soda to remove the grape stain. Marshall becomes a jealous tough guy and challenges him to a fight, but nothing happens.
Back in Philly, Ted and Barney head back to the airport, but Barney wants to take a detour to the Liberty Bell to lick it. Ted is pissed, and questions why he even hangs out with him. Barney gives Ted a speech about living life, which changes Ted's mind. They go lick the Liberty Bell, and Ted realizes that Barney and the risks that he brings are what make life fun, and give him some great stories to tell his future kids.

Some notes:
-This is the first episode with multiple storylines, since the characters are not all together for the majority of the episode. I believe this is also the first use of "Legendary" and "Legen - wait for it - dary."
-It looks like CBS covered up the logo on Barney's down jacket.
-Marshall drives a Pontiac Fiero.
-The girls on the plane mention that their boyfriends are both linebackers on the Philadelphia Eagles. LBs on the 2005 Eagles included Dhani Jones, Jeremiah Trotter, Keith Adams, Justin Ena, Alonzo Jackson, Mike Labinjo, Matt McCoy, Zeke Moreno, Dedrick Roper, Jason Short, and Mark Simoneau.
-Barney: "Cute girls are not from Buffalo."
Nitpicking:
-At the beginning of the episode, when Barney tells Marshall to get in the cab, Marshall responds with "Lily and I are...," before Barney cuts him off. However, the episode reveals that Marshall spent the evening studying, while Lily had plans with Robin. Possible mistake, or was Marshall trying to get out of going out with Barney?
-When Ted and Barney first get to the airport in NY, Ted asks Barney about the suitcases that he has with him. Why wouldn't Ted ask about this when Barney was getting them out of the cab, or had Ted just not noticed yet?
-Would a martini really only cost six dollars in a New York bar in 2005? That seems low, since that price seems about right for bars in less pricey areas.





